Just Jessica
We Don't Hold Seats for People Who Haven't Decided
Becoming

We Don't Hold Seats for People Who Haven't Decided

November 18, 2026 · 5 min

Send to a friend

He says he's not sure what he wants. After 40, you don't owe anyone a reserved seat. How to spot indecision, what waiting costs, and what to say.

If someone can’t decide whether they want to be with you, that is the decision. You don’t owe an undecided person a reserved spot in your life. Holding the seat costs you time, attention, and the chance to meet someone who already knows. After 40, a clear yes is the minimum, not a bonus.

JustJessica

There is a little folded card on restaurant tables that says RESERVED.

I used to be that card.

A man would say, “I really like you, I’m just not sure what I want right now,” and I would sit down in my own life, fold myself into a neat little triangle, and guard a chair for him. Through dinner. Through dessert. Through the whole season.

Meanwhile he was out in the parking lot. Deciding.

I’m 44. I have five kids, including two sets of twins, and I have run a household off a calendar that would make an air traffic controller ask for a nap. I do not have the bandwidth to babysit a grown man’s indecision.

And I finally figured out I’m not required to.

We don’t hold seats for people who haven’t decided.

The Reserved Sign: What “I’m Not Sure Right Now” Really Means

Here’s the part nobody wants to hear, including me, for about a decade.

“I don’t know what I want” is an answer. It’s just not the one you were hoping for.

People who want you rearrange things. They make a plan and keep it. They text back like a person with thumbs. They don’t need a committee meeting with their feelings every other Thursday.

Sometimes the undecided person is being honest. Good for him. Honest is better than strung along. But his honesty doesn’t sign you up to wait. He gets to be unsure. You get to be unavailable.

You are not alone in the waiting room, either.

I Swore

The Waiting Room Tax: What Holding a Seat Really Costs

Waiting looks free. It is not free. It bills you monthly.

It costs you time. Three months of “let’s see where it goes” becomes a year before you notice the calendar flipped.

It costs you attention. Rereading a four-word text like it’s a ransom note. Checking whether he watched your story. Doing forensic analysis on a thumbs-up.

It costs you peace. Your body stays on standby, half relaxed, half braced.

And if you have kids, it costs you a little of them. Mine notice when I’m checking my phone at the dinner table. They notice when my mood depends on whether someone texted back. I don’t want to teach them that love looks like hovering.

The sneakiest cost is the one you can’t see: the person who might have walked in and found your seat already taken. By a coat. Belonging to a man in the parking lot.

A survey found 14% of singles admitted staying in a situationship just because the attention felt nice. I get it. Attention feels nice. But attention is a sample, not a meal.

Slow and Sure vs. Undecided: How to Tell the Difference

I’m not saying rush. Slow is fine. Slow can be lovely. Slow and undecided are not the same animal, and after divorce it’s easy to confuse them.

The difference is direction. A slow person is walking toward you at a reasonable speed. An undecided person is standing still and asking you to stay put too.

Closing the Reservation: What to Say When Someone Can’t Decide

You don’t need a speech. You don’t need an ultimatum dressed up as a boundary. An ultimatum tries to control what he does. A boundary just tells the truth about what you’ll do.

Here’s the text I’d send:

“I like you. I’m looking for someone who already knows. If that changes for you, you know how to reach me. Until then, I’m not holding the seat.”

Then the hard part. You actually stop holding it.

No checking his stories. No “just saw this and thought of you” meme at 11:40 p.m. No leaving the door cracked with your foot in it.

If he decides later, he can make a reservation like everybody else.

The Open Table: Life After You Stop Saving Seats

I’d love to tell you that the minute I stopped saving seats, the right man walked in carrying flowers and a working calendar.

That’s not what happened.

What happened is some Friday nights got quiet. I ate takeout with my feet on the coffee table and nobody to text. Some nights that felt like freedom. Some nights it felt like a lot of chairs.

But I stopped performing patience for people who weren’t coming. I got my attention back. My kids got a mom who was at the table instead of in her phone.

The chair across from me is empty right now. I’m sitting in mine.

Tell me in the comments: What’s the longest you ever held a seat for someone who never sat down? No judgment. I’ll go first.

Keep reading

I Swore

FAQ

What does it mean when he says he doesn’t know what he wants?

Usually it means he doesn’t want a commitment with you right now, even if he enjoys your company. Sometimes it’s honest uncertainty, and that’s fair. But uncertainty is still an answer. You can respect it without reorganizing your life around it or waiting for it to change on its own timeline.

How long should you wait for someone to decide if they want a relationship?

There’s no magic number, but watch direction, not the calendar. If after a few months he still can’t say where things stand, still avoids plans, and still runs hot and cold, waiting longer rarely changes the answer. After 40, most people know what they want much sooner than they say.

Is taking it slow the same as being undecided?

No. Someone taking it slow is moving toward you at a gentle pace: making plans, keeping them, and telling you where things stand. Someone undecided is standing still and asking you to stay put. Slow has direction. Undecided has a holding pattern.

How do I tell someone I’m not waiting anymore?

Keep it short and kind: “I like you. I’m looking for someone who already knows. If that changes, you know how to reach me.” Then follow through by stepping back. The words matter less than actually stopping the checking, chasing, and leaving the door cracked.

What if he comes back after he decides?

Then you get to decide too, from a full life instead of a waiting room. Look for changed behavior, not just changed words: consistent plans, clear intentions, and effort that doesn’t vanish when things get comfortable. Coming back is a request, not a reservation you owe him.

With Love, Just Jessica

— Jessica

Send to a friend
Free guide